Friday, 4 November 2022

Better government with fair votes

C of E and PR

"If proportional representation is good enough for the General Synod, why not for the country’s voting system?"This article in "Church Times" of 21 October in support of PR is well worth reading and quoting. You can also write a letter to the Editor to support the article or to respond to letters that others have written.  PR_ChurchTimes_21.10.22

Labour and PR

Although the Labour Party Conference voted for PR on 26 September, Sir Keir Starmer has said that PR is not a priority for him and it will not be in Labour’s manifesto for the next general election.

Would you please sign the petition [LabourPRpetition]LabourPRpetition22 for Labour to put PR in its next manifesto?  You can also write direct to Sir Keir at leader@labour.org.uk   Those of you who have Labour MPs may like to write to them.

What did British People vote for?

This is an extract from Suella Braverman’s resignation letter of 19 October:

“They [the British people] deserve policing they can respect, an immigration policy they want and voted for in such unambiguous numbers at the last election”.

This isn’t the place to discuss the rights and wrongs of the Government’s immigration policy (or the Government’s difficulties generally), but the British people voted for it in such unambiguous numbers?  Only 43.6% of voters (29.3% of British electors as there was a 67.3% turnout) voted Conservative but I don’t think any journalists or commentators picked up on that.

The Instability of FPTP

MP Gillian Keegan, has become the fifth Education Secretary in only four months.  We have also had five Chancellors in four months.

We are now on our third Prime Minister in two months and the fifth in six years.  There have been four Home Secretaries (including Suella Braverman twice) in only two months!

Do opponents of proportional representation still claim that First Past The Post voting provides stability?

[Acknowledgements to Anthony Tuffin of the Campaign for Real Democracy]



Thursday, 3 November 2022

One step forward, one stand-still and leap back to the darkness

 In Brazil, Jair Bolsonaro has tacitly accepted that he lost the presidential run-off election. Without mentioning his conqueror, Lula da Silva by name, he has assured that there will be a peaceful handover. This in spite of factors more favourable to a seizure of power than were available to Trump when his supporters stormed the Capitol. He probably calculates that, as a relatively young man in presidential terms, time is on his side but let us be thankful for a rare peaceful transition.

On Tuesday, there was a general election in Denmark. Social democratic and moderate parties in narrowly resisted the threat from more extremist parties to look to remain in power. 

On the same day, the reverse occurred in Israel. The hope that a wide-ranging coalition government would continue and eventually reduce the tension there was snuffed out. Likud, led by a man who faces serious criminal charges, looks like being returned to power with the support of "far-right politicians Itamar Ben-Gvir, who openly calls for armed violence against Palestinians, and Bezalel Smotrich, who are both part of Israel’s Religious Zionism alliance. Ben Gvir has advocated for Palestinians in Israel to undergo 'loyalty tests', with those deemed 'disloyal' expelled from their ancestral homeland."  (from al Jazeera)'s report) Ben-Gvir's party will be the third most numerous in the Knesset. There has been violent repression of minority groups in Israel under what was apparently a moderate government. Worse will probably come if such violence is officially sanctioned.


Wednesday, 2 November 2022

Go Chineke!

 I have almost the same feeling about Black History Month as Tom Lehrer does about the USA's  National Brotherhood Week. It is rather tokenistic, like "taking the knee" before Premier League football matches. The Black Lives Matter movement has not increased the number of non-white football managers or administrators since the gesture started.

Still, the Month did have a good affect on BBC 4 last Sunday. First, the Chineke! orchestra played unjustly neglected works by Coleridge Taylor (also Radio 3's composer of the week this week) and Sowande. Then there was a repeat of the Lenny Henry/Suzy Klein survey of historical black classical composers and performers. There should be a follow-up to this, though. There was no mention of William Grant Still, who surely contributed to a distinctive American sound in the concert-hall and on movie sound tracks. He was a symphonist on his own account as well as an arranger for the Paul Whiteman orchestra. Contemporary composers like Laura Mvula, who ranges widely across the musical field should feature. There are others.

 In the meantime, Chineke thrives.


Tuesday, 1 November 2022

Former chancellor speaks out

 Now that he is freed from the constraints of the Commons, Phillip Hammond, now Lord Hammond, is free to criticise the leadership of his party. On the plunge in the UK's financial reputation after the Kwarteng special statement, he said: "this is the result of allowing ideology to triumph over common sense". (One could say the same about many government decisions over the last decade, including Brexit.)

Last Sunday, he also stated the truth that his former colleagues have found it difficult to face, that taxes have to rise in order to preserve the social services of a first-world country. Borrowing is no longer an option.


Monday, 31 October 2022

Bridges

 Among many disasters taking more than a hundred lives this weekend has been this man-made one. The supporting cables of a suspension bridge in Gujarat state failed plunging at least 130 people to their deaths. The bridge dated from the days of the Raj in the 19th century.

Another 19th century suspension bridge, the Menai, which links Ynys Mon to the mainland, has been closed to all road traffic apart from emergency vehicles below a certain weight. This closure may last into next year as hangers are checked and replaced as necessary. There will be serious effects on trade, but in view of what appears to have been a  premature reopening in Gujarat, surely the precautionary principle must apply.

Friday, 28 October 2022

Welsh GPs settle for lower-than-inflation pay rise

 It has to be said that 4.5% uplift to a GP's income is more than 4.5% than a nurse's or a teacher's salary and that the Welsh government should do more to address the very real difficulties that those essential people are having in the current economic climate. However, the settlement just reached is a positive step.

The new contract will lift many non-monetary burdens from GPs which clearly were a major disincentive to doctors to staying on within the service in Wales. The burden on nurses, causing them to leave the profession which they joined out of love, is the overwork caused in a feedback loop by too many leaving the profession. Now that is a problem which can be solved by putting more money on the table, raiding other budgets if necessary. The consequential from the stamp duty cut could have been a start.


Thursday, 27 October 2022

The ERG versus the people

 In the sort of deviousness we came to expect from Jacob Rees-Mogg, the then Business Secretary was true to form last Tuesday morning. In response to a question from an Opposition MP he neatly avoided the real point and instead puffed his own Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill 2022-23 which would if enacted make things worse for Dame Meg's constituent.

The problem, as Rees-Mogg well knows, is not UK red tape, but Brussels paperwork which is now necessary as the UK is now a third country.

Sunak had a clean slate and could have killed this obnoxious Bill, but chose not to. In one way, it probably will solve all the brewers' problems because, seeing the sweeping away of all remaining EU standards, the Commission will probably rule that those businesses will not be permitted to import into the EU in future.

The deceiver Rees-Mogg has been replaced by the man with the multiple personalities, Grant Shapps.


Wednesday, 26 October 2022

Yesterday's men and women

 My hopes of last Monday have been dashed. Not only has Suella Braverman, the supreme advocate of banning all immigration (except presumably Indians under a deal with Modi) and public demonstrations, been reappointed Home Secretary. At the same time, Dominic Raab has been brought back to the Ministry of Justice. At the time of his appointment as Foreign Secretary, it was reported that "Dominic Raab is on record as being against the so-called 'values agenda' – code for human rights – and has almost always voted against any development of anti-prejudice and discrimination laws". 

Elsewhere, old faces have been brought back, often to their previous Departments, presumably in the interests of continuity and competence. But the appointments which affect civil society go beyond that and suggest that Sunak wants to stifle dissent and at the same time continue feeding red meat to the racist element of Tory support.