Thursday, 18 May 2023

Water treatment: we want action, not apologies

 Water UK chair Ruth Kelly's performance on BBC TV News yesterday recalled reminiscences of songwriter Johnny Mercer. Sober and by day, he was the epitome of the Southern gentleman. But, as one obituarist recalled:

he was one of those drinkers whose personality changed. He had the reputation of being a "mean drunk," even to the extent of many times insulting the hostess of a party given in his honor. But the next day remorse set in, and he sent apologies in the form of roses.

Apparently, one of those hostesses on receiving the latest such bouquet sent him a message to the effect: "I don't want your damned roses, just the nice you."

Sufferers from repeated sewage overflows and discharges over the years are not interested in warm words. They want long-overdue action to repair and upgrade the sewage infrastructure of England and Wales. Even Dŵr Cymru, which is not subject to shareholder pressure to maximise profit is not guiltless, though it could be argued that industrial south Wales suffered more than most from rapid unregulated building of infrastructure in the Industrial Revolution, so that the burden of correcting the errors of the past is all the greater.

 Faced with the enormous bills which the modernisation of our water and sewage systems required, and wanting to keep public spending down, Mrs Thatcher off-loaded the problem on to the private sector. She may even have naively believed that private sector efficiency and access to loan capital would transform the water industry. Instead, its new masters treated it as a cash cow and we have suffered ever since. It is impractical to re-nationalise the system, but it is not too much to hope that the water regulator Ofwat takes more vigorous action over transgressions, even if it has to be given more teeth.


Wednesday, 17 May 2023

Tuesday, 16 May 2023

How much did Tory donor know about money-laundering?

 The BBC is clearly very sure of its ground in naming top businessman Javed Marandi as a person of interest in a current investigation into money-laundering. 

Mr Marandi, 55, was born in Iran and grew up in London, where he still lives.

His ties to the Conservative Party emerged through reports of his generous donations. Between 2014 and 2020, he gave £633,800 according to Electoral Commission records.

[...]

He owns the iconic design brand, The Conran Shop, a stake in Anya Hindmarch Ltd, the luxury handbag firm, and an exclusive private members' club and hotel in Oxfordshire.

Along with his wife, he heads the Marandi Foundation, which funds the Prince and Princess of Wales's charity.

In 2021, Mr Marandi became a special adviser to homelessness charity Centrepoint, providing guidance on how it could expand its work with disadvantaged young people.

None of Mr Marandi's UK businesses or these organisations form any part of the NCA's investigation, which looked at earlier events.

The Organised Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP) revealed how $2.9bn (£2.3bn) of dirty money - cash stolen from Azerbaijan's people and economy - had been spirited away by members of the country's elite. It was largely for their own benefit, but also to bribe European politicians.

Money route

According to documents from the NCA's case at Westminster Magistrates' Court, the suspect money that made its way to the Feyziyev family accounts in London had originated in bank accounts belonging to a company with neither employees, nor traceable records of its activities.Based in Baku, Azerbaijan's capital, Baktelekom looked like a state-owned firm that has an almost identical name.

District Judge John Zani found that "substantial funds from this criminal enterprise" were then moved into two bank accounts in the Baltics belonging to Glasgow-registered shell companies.

Some of the cash was then moved onwards to accounts linked to Javanshir Feyziyev and Javad Marandi, according to the NCA.


There are more details in the BBC report.

Saturday, 13 May 2023

Dangerous talk among Conservatives

 Liberal England draws attention to the Bournemouth symposium organised by the Conservative Democratic Organisation (CDO), the party-within-a-party which supports Boris Johnson. The i newspaper quotes a passage which it says will appear in a keynote speech by the former Home Secretary, Priti Patel, criticising Rishi Sunak for "taking down a vote-winning political giant who was on course to secure a record-breaking fifth consecutive general election win for our party".

This delusion is apparently shared by many Tories. They seek to blame Sunak for English voters' putsch of Conservative councillors up and down the land, whereas - local issues apart - local electors formed their view of the Conservative brand based on the whole of the last four years, for most of which Johnson occupied No. 10. They do not accept that Sunak and Hunt have in fact steadied the economy. Confidence abroad is rising. After some profit-taking on the back of the Bank of England's latest rate rise, sterling has settled on a dollar value 3-4% above last year's. Admittedly, middle- to low-earners will not see the benefit of the drop in inflation which is clearly on the way, but they would hardly vote Conservative anyway. 

Political strategists in opposition parties clearly want the Tory rebellion to succeed. They know that a clearly divided party does not win elections. They also intuit that Johnson, having been seen through by the electorate with the help of the media, will be a vote-loser rather than a vote-winner. They would like nothing better than to see Johnson back on the political throne. But what would be good for Labour, Liberal Democrats and the Nationalists almost certainly spells disaster for the economy. For the sake of the country, CDO must not succeed.

Jonathan Calder suggests that the Conservative grass-roots are more extreme than the leadership, just as they were in Margaret Thatcher's day. Apparently, it was grass-roots pressure which caused the community charge (poll tax) to be rushed into operation rather than be phased in over ten years as was originally envisaged. Certainly, there is a lot of Johnson support out there, but I believe the picture is more mixed. There were actually two Conservative council gains amidst the bloodbath last Thursday. The i reports that in both Torbay and Wyre Forest, the successful campaigns were built on local issues, leg-work and "back to basics". Torbay's new leader puts his faith in his prime minister turning round the fortunes of the party, and that is echoed by Wyre Forest's Tory group leader: "The one thing Rishi has done is to restore an element of stability".

It will be too late to save the Tories, of course, but it should mean that there is a stable economy for an incoming progressive government to build on in 2024, Clearly Labour is set to be the largest party, but in a hung parliament, Liberal Democrats will be able to drive a hard bargain for their support. Hopefully, this time the parliamentary leadership will not drop the ball as they did in 2011.



Friday, 12 May 2023

Migration

 Sunak and Braverman's Illegal Migration Bill rightly had a mauling when it reached the Lords on Wednesday. It was even attacked by Andrew Green, the co-founder of Migration Watch UK, for not addressing the real concerns of his organisation. There were many fine speeches in the Second Reading debate, including several by Liberal Democrats. Mike German, former leader of the Welsh Liberal Democrats, made a telling contribution citing a real case where an abused victim of trafficking, now safe, would have been thrown out under the Bill being discussed. There was praise from Lord Alton, a former Lib Dem now on the cross-benches, for Theresa May. She had

steered the landmark modern-day slavery and human trafficking legislation through Parliament, providing pre-legislative scrutiny and building bipartisan and bicameral consensus and support. Last week, with my noble and learned friend Lady Butler-Sloss and the noble Lord, Lord McColl of Dulwich, we spent an hour with Lady May and Sir Iain Duncan Smith. I hope that when the Minister replies, he will explain why their amendment on trafficking victims, alluded to by the noble Lord, Lord Forsyth, in his remarks, has not been accepted.

Let us be clear: the changes proposed in the Bill will not stop the boats, as modern slavery victims are just 6% of small boat arrivals. However, it will remove support and protection from many genuine victims, and will deter slavery victims exploited on British soil from coming forward, leaving them trapped in exploitation and making prosecuting criminal gangs even harder.


I was particularly struck by the contribution of another cross-bencher who was once a leading Liberal Democrat. Alex Carlile, Baron Carlile of Berriew, had been a government adviser on terrorism and, while a supporter of the European Court of Human Rights, has consistently pointed out its flaws. No soft liberal, he. So the government should have paid attention to his speech: 
He was followed by Baroness Sugg, a Conservative peer, who raised questions about the treatment of pregnant women, of unaccompanied children, of victims of modern slavery, the lack of safe and legal routes for refugees and the unacceptable backlog of immigration and asylum claims; In conclusion, she echoed the concern from all sides of the Lords:
my noble friend will be well aware of the concerns from many eminent Members of your Lordships’ House, the UNHCR and many others that, as the Bill stands, it would breach the UK’s obligations under international refugee law. I hope that during the passage of the Bill the Government will be able to reassure noble Lords that it does not breach international law or international obligations, including the European Convention on Human Rights. That is not a position we should be in.

It seems to me that if the Lords' Committee does its job in removing the bad parts of the Bill, there will be virtually nothing left of it. There is sadly little prospect of this government accepting any of their Lordships' amendments, but at least the committee discussions will delay its enactment.

Thursday, 11 May 2023

Heat And Dust

 "Receiving a rare showing" (Radio Times reviewer) last Wednesday on Film4 was "Heat and Dust", the culmination of Merchant-Ivory's India-set films. Merchant-Ivory Productions is now associated with a particular kind of period drama centred on the works of E.M. Forster and Henry James, but the partnership made their first real money from productions largely financed by major studios who, at that time of strict Indian currency controls, could not repatriate their rupee profits. Clearly production costs were lower in addition. One cannot imagine the big set-piece banquets, processions etc. of "Heat and Dust" being shot these days except perhaps for the guaranteed box-office of a Bond movie. It was also beautifully photographed. It was not surface glitz, though, a criticism which has stuck to later Merchant-Ivory films. The themes of colonialism, of convention - both Indian and British - and the interplay between them dominate the film.

Any production which boasts both Greta Scacchi and Julie Christie has a head-start, but the whole thing was perfectly cast. The cutting between the two time periods (1921 and 1982)  was clear, unlike some more modern movies. I did find certain passages within the same time-frames too episodic, but I accept that is a matter of personal taste. More pertinent, perhaps, is the character played by Nickolas Grace, who links the two periods, does not seem to have aged the requisite 60 years.

Sadly, the 1982 segment, originally a modern contrast with the fractious relationship between Indians and British, also appears as a period piece now. Anne (Julie Christie) relates how a tomb built in the past by a Nawab, a Muslim, is now treated as "sacred by both Hindus and Muslims", who jointly participate in an annual festival at the shrine. One wonders if those days will return to a country now in thrall to Hindu nationalism.


Wednesday, 10 May 2023

Fascism must not be confused with Nazism

Michael Rosen's guest on Radio 4's Word of Mouth yesterday was Jacob Stanley, author of How Propaganda Works (2015) and How Fascism Works (2018). The two had a valuable discussion, but I would quarrel with the good professor's assignment to "fascism" the worst excesses of Hitler and Himmler. The point is that fascism has been clearly defined in a book by Giovanni Gentile and Benito Mussolini, the man who coined the term. It does not necessarily involve genocide; this was an evil twist added by the Nazis. Indeed, many Italian Jews initially supported Mussolini's rise to power. It was only later that the Italian dictator followed Hitler in turning against Judaism. Even then, only a minority of Italy's Jews were sent north to the death camps.

I am not defending fascism. Its underlying illiberal philosophy is anathema. Nobody should have to live in a conformist militarist state ruled by a single strong man whose every word is law, and where dissent is forbidden. But one should be precise in the use of language. "Fascist" in particular has been thrown about as an insult, usually inappropriately.

Having said all that, the Rosen-Stanley discussion turned up some disturbing parallels between then and now. The sort of language used by Mussolini and his cohorts to gain populist support is cropping up again on both sides of the Atlantic, not to mention Moscow and Budapest. A wedge has been inserted into our democracy. We must ensure that it is not driven in further.