An English bibliotaph of fifty years residence in Wales pontificates about politics (slightly off-message), films and trivia. Acting secretary of Aberavon and Neath Liberal Democrats. Candidate for Neath in the Westminster elections of 1997 & 2017 and the Welsh general election of 2016.
Sunday, 28 May 2023
What would Lord Denning say?
Friday, 26 May 2023
Finland shows the way on "fake news"
Yesterday's i newspaper told how primary school children in Finland are taught "how to traverse the turbulent and often toxic digital landscape so that they can assess news stories, challenge conspiracy theories, handle data and spot hate speech".
The article goes on:
These are the children of Generation Z - digital natives of the post-truth age, brought up from infancy using the internet, social media, tablets and mobile phones. Yet in Finland, a country famous for one of the world's finest and most equitable education systems, they are also taught critical thinking, from an early age to help them resist the flood of fake news and conspiracy theories.
The UK would do well to learn from these lessons, too, Democracies face increasingly fraught online struggles against dictatorships, fanatics and fraudsters, with artificial intelligence looming to make the fight even harder - so we need to do everything possible to equip our own children for the realities of the world in which they live.
When early years education in Wales was overhauled by Kirsty Williams and her team, the Finnish system was borne in mind. I would like to think that Jeremy Miles, MS for Neath and the current education minister, is looking to Finland again.
Thursday, 25 May 2023
Police in London and Cardiff need to answer questions
Yesterday, a lady finally gave up the ghost after being struck by a police motorcyclist on 10th May. The outrider was part of a police escort for Sophie, Duchess of Edinburgh, the King's sister-in-law. One has to accept that in these dangerous times even minor royalty needs protection. However, questions must arise as to whether Metropolitan Police standards are going down. It is understood that police enquiries are continuing, with more witnesses to the incident being sought. An independent inquiry should not be ruled out.
On the same day, two teenagers died in a suburb of Cardiff after being followed by a police van. South Wales Police initially denied that a pursuit had taken place until independent domestic surveillance footage submitted to the BBC showed the teenagers on an electric bike being followed by the van. There was then a more nuanced statement from the police who admitted that the pair had been followed for a time but suggested that it had not been a "pursuit" because the van was not sounding its siren or flashing its lights. Further, there was no police vehicle within fifty yards of the scene of the fatal crash. Locals later pointed out that this was because bollards prevented the van continuing to follow the teenagers.
It seems that Ely has been plagued by youngsters joy-riding on two-wheelers, which may even have been stolen. Residents would be entitled to some protection by the police, but not high-speed chases through an area of housing. It is clear that feeling in the area is on the side of the families of the victims, rather than the police, with whom relations seem to have been broken for some time. There will be an inquiry by the Independent Office for Police Conduct.
Through all this, the conduct of the Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC), Alun Michael, has been less than admirable. As readers will probably know, the Liberal Democrat party has consistently opposed the institution of PCCs. They are "elected by the public to hold Chief Constables and the force to account, making the police answerable to the communities they serve" as the official Association website has it. Instead, Mr Michael has acted merely as a spokesman for the police force, repeating the briefing that he had clearly been given. Clearly, one expects a PCC to stand up for the police within his area if they have been unfairly criticised, but to leap to their defence when there is doubt about their conduct and all the facts are not known is hardly "making the police answerable". The old system of chief constables being called to account by a committee of councillors, who are in constant touch with their electorate, was more effective. In South Wales at least, the post of Commissioner has shown itself to be little more than a sinecure.
Wednesday, 24 May 2023
An apology saved up for the right occasion
Tuesday, 23 May 2023
The Mounties at 150
The Canadian Parliament passed an Act on 23rd May 1873 establishing the North-West Mounted Police.
Monday, 22 May 2023
Rail reliability
One of rail's selling-points is that it can (properly maintained) keep going when exceptionally bad weather stops normal road transport. There was a striking illustration of this in the mid-1960s. There was a pressure group named "Rail Into Road" or something similar, led by prominent motoring enthusiasts, including the designer and racing motorist Sydney Allard. Their pitch was that rail was no longer economically viable and that railway lines should be torn up and wherever practicable turned into roads. A successful media campaign led to a meeting arranged at St Christopher House, then the Ministry of Transport HQ. Unfortunately, there was a snowstorm on the arranged date, and the only representative of the group who made it to Southwark Street was Sydney Allard, who took the precaution of travelling by train.
Sunday, 21 May 2023
Caring Conservatism is not quite dead ...
.. though Tory governments from Margaret Thatcher's onwards have almost extinguished it.
There was a Backbench Business Committee debate on public access to nature, launched by Green MP Caroline Lucas, in the Commons last Thursday. Apart from some well-deserved criticism of the government for not doing enough, there was rare cross-party agreement about the benefits of opening up the natural world. The absence of a time limit also made for some well-developed arguments.
I was particularly struck by the contribution of Richard Graham, the Conservative member for Gloucester. He began by remarking how easy it was to escape from the city to well-known beauty spots like the Cotswolds and the Malvern Hills. But his main theme was how the council and local activists had managed to bring nature into the city. At times, he sounded like a Liberal Democrat.
Colleagues have made points about people from ethnic minority communities who live further from nature than others. That is true in some parts of the country, no doubt, but in a city our size of only 5.5 square miles, where we have a primary school that has more than 50 nationalities, we are all very close to the extraordinary combination of the canal, the hill, the river and the lakes. The question is, does everyone have equal inspiration and drive to go and find, use and draw pleasure from those great natural assets? That is where schools play a major part.At Matson and Robinswood, towards the great hill, we have done a huge amount. When I say “we”, I mean everybody collectively. Nobody should try to take individual ownership, because we must encourage everybody to create and to take individual and collective community ownership to make these projects sustainable and successful for more generations. Matson Park has improved, as has Haycroft Drive. We can see similar trends across the constituency of allowing more wild flowers and meadows, with paths through them. That greatly increases the amount of insects and birds that we can all see on our walks or cycle rides around the city.
Saturday, 20 May 2023
Ed Davey should go further
One can count on ones fingers the number of Westminster party leaders who were born or brought up in difficult circumstances: David Lloyd George, Ramsay MacDonald, James Callaghan and possibly John Major come to mind. (All twentieth century, one notes. Labour/TU sponsorship began in the 1870s and MPs were not paid until 1911. Until then, MPs needed independent income to sustain their political careers.) Surely none could have received more body blows in life than Ed Davey and his wife Emily, as the article referred to in the local party's blog lays out in detail. To have reached a seat at the cabinet table after all that is a tribute to Ed's fortitude.
There were some achievements in the face of Conservative opposition, too. He and Vince Cable stopped the programme of closure of post offices, begun by John Major and continued under Blair and Brown. He allowed newcomers to break into the charmed circle of big energy companies, though he was not to know how poor regulation would allow several in with poor economic structures which were bound to fail.
However, I would contend that he (and fellow Liberal Democrat ministers) could have done more to prevent the 2011 reversal of much that the coalition had achieved in its first year, even to the extent of threatening to pull out of the coalition (the terms of which the Conservative Health minister had already broken). How Osborne and company persuaded Nick Clegg that his party would lose more seats in an immediate general election than if they saw out the full term is a mystery. Further, for all Clegg's undoubted charm, there should have come a point when fellow-ministers should have ceased following him like sheep. The party on the back benches had already seen the feet of clay and would surely have backed a rebellion.
That Guardian article is headed with an apology. "We didn’t show we cared enough. We won’t make that mistake twice". I believe he should go further, and admit that he got it wrong over a whole slew of policies from selling Royal Mail on the cheap, through failing to maintain PPE in the NHS to signing away nuclear power generation to the French and Chinese. For someone who used to campaign against nuclear power, that was some U-turn. He should come clean over these things now, because otherwise they will come back with more force during next year's general election campaign.
Nor is a simple "I hate Tories" message right for the time, though it may be effective come the election. In this period between the English local elections and the general, we should be emphasising our unique brand, as in Zoe Williams' final quote from Ed “I believe in our environmental stuff, I believe in our political reform, I believe in our internationalism, I believe in civil liberties, I believe in our support for public services, I believe we’re caring," - and a return to at least a European free trade area, I would add.