Wednesday, 28 February 2018

Auditing prominent companies

Vince Cable has drawn attention to the lack of competition in the audit market. If Adam Smith were alive today, he would surely suspect a "concert party".

As Private Eye has frequently pointed out, there is also a danger of a conflict of interest when an audit firm provides additional management advice to the company it is auditing - not that I am suggesting this is what happened in the Carillion case.

Tuesday, 27 February 2018

Hand-wringing in Westminster

Many pious words were spoken in the Commons yesterday in the wake of failure of the UN-mandated cease-fire in Eastern Ghouta. All sides of the House knew implicitly that the time when the UK could influence affairs in Syria, let alone do any good, had long past.

Seven years ago, when the Syrian authorities responded violently to a civil demonstration, the coalition government had several choices:

  • do nothing, but advise Assad that he risked destroying his nation if he continued to overreact with force;
  • go into Syria with sufficient force (including ground forces) to affect régime change;
  • incite a rebellion which had no chance of success without external support.


Sadly, our government chose the third. At least the UK and the US stepped back from the threat of merely crippling Assad's defences, which would surely have led to a Daesh dictatorship in Damascus far worse than any other in the Middle East.

As it is, much of the country including many historic sites has been laid waste, long-established communities have been brutalised and the standing of both Russia and Iran has been improved, which is surely not what the West would have wanted.

Monday, 26 February 2018

Worboys, Bennell ... and Eichmann

Ian Walker's great piece on Hannah Arendt and the Eichmann trial in last week's New European revived Arendt's great question: Why? Summarising a complex article about a complex woman and her work is beyond me, but I would say that although Arendt opened our eyes to facets of evil, she did not find an answer to her own question.

Juxtaposing Eichmann, who was responsible for the smooth administration of the murder of millions, with two men who killed nobody - directly - may seem bizarre, but to me their depredations raise the same question: what made them? We know the reason for the magnitude of their crimes: Worboys and Bennell because people who were in a position to put a stop to their activities turned a blind eye, Eichmann because he worked for a racist régime which was for a long time untouchable. What we do not know is what made them the people they were.

Worboys and Bennell did not murder anybody, but they irreparably damaged their victims psychologically. Bennell could see the effects day-to-day, as most of "his" boys stayed in his training squads and even Worboys must have had some idea of the damage he had caused when he dumped his victims.

Sunday, 25 February 2018

Guilt by association

It is hard to see why the red-tops are smearing Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn as a commie puppet. The tenuous Czech connection has been forensically dismissed by a BBC reporter with access to the Czech secret service archives, and Paul Anderson, who was a Tribune journalist in the period in question, has put the affair in context. The real danger of Corbyn is not his threat to renationalise the railway (with which even many long-suffering commuters from the Conservative home counties have sympathy) but his unholy alliance with Mrs May. He seems determined to augment the Brexiteers' drive to a poorer (except for financial speculators) United Kingdom outside the single market not only of the EU but also EFTA. (The prospect of "a" customs union which is different from the existing customs union has been held out by Labour's shadow foreign secretary Emily Thornberry, but this is clearly the sort of "cherry-picking" which has already been dismissed by negotiators for the EU 27.) So why are the Tory-leaning tabloids attacking Corbyn now, years away from a general election?

Social media have also unearthed CIA records which mark Corbyn as suspicious - because he had close contacts with workers organisations around the world. There seems to be a general feeling in the US establishment (based presumably on their own experience) that all trade unions everywhere are either controlled by the Mafia or are communist front organisations.  Worse in their eyes are the TUC equivalents who dare to criticise the way that régimes favoured by the US suppress human or workers' rights or both.

Perhaps there is no specific reason for attacking Corbyn at this time. Perhaps the grandiose claims of a minor Czech agent who feels he has been forgotten have stimulated a minor press feeding-frenzy. This would be even more worrying. There are already signs reminiscent of the McCarthyism of the 1950s US, when careers could be threatened because of a youthful dalliance with socialist ideas or merely because of attraction to communist front organisations.

I "like" a Facebook page dedicated to Jammu and Kashmir, because I feel that the heartless anomaly created by the Indian independence settlement should be corrected. I stress that this should be negotiated away, hopefully through the good offices of the Commonwealth or otherwise by friends of both India and Pakistan. I reject the use of force, either by governments or terrorist organisations. However, it is very probable that there are other members of the group who are tied to Islamist extremism, which seeks to capitalise violently on the grievances of Kashmiris. Should I fear a knock on the door from Special Branch because of this coincidence?

This is just one personal example. In a world shrunk by the World Wide Web and globalisation, it would be easy to find links from anybody to anybody else. Let us hope common sense and objectivity prevail.

Saturday, 24 February 2018

Friday, 23 February 2018

Libraries declining in Wales

BBC reported earlier this week that the number of professional librarians in Wales had declined by a fifth while the number of volunteers had increased 13-fold. The decline in facilities has not been as steep as in England, but it is part of a national trend. There is little doubt that if free libraries were not prescribed by law, many local authorities would have done away with them altogether.

There is still a place for the public library, if only because of the wealth of material published before 1997 when the World Wide Web really took off. The main libraries are already information centres rather than just a collection of bookshelves. However,, professionals are needed to guide the ordinary citizen. The popular Web search engines by their commercial nature bias their results towards the new and the paid-for links.

Thursday, 22 February 2018

Where will Macron's party go next?

The next European Parliament elections will likely take place from 23rd to 26th May 2019. There is already speculation as to how many French seats will be taken by President Macron's party and whether he will have enough MEPs to go it alone or whether his people will join one of the other blocs in the parliament. Most opinion in Brussels points to En Marche joining ALDE, which would move that party even more towards economic rather than social liberalism. However, there is a minority view that EPP, the broad conservative grouping would be more to his liking. This graphic shows more: