Tuesday, 9 May 2023

More than a little progress

 It turns out that I was over-cautious in my reference to "some progress" in my post of last Friday. The local party relays the score so far from federal HQ here. There is still one result to come, from Longbeck ward in Redcar & Cleveland where they had to give up recounting on Friday and will resume today. In what appears to have been a straight fight between Conservatives and Independents, no Liberal Democrat is involved in the ward so there will be no effect on our final tally.

What makes that tally more impressive is that it was achieved in wards last contested in 2019, when the party did well in local authority elections. There were even some pessimists in the party who worried that we might struggle to hold on to all those gains. By contrast, both Labour and Conservatives had fallen back in 2019, council gains being outweighed by losses in both cases. Labour did come out ahead on Friday, their 22 council gains more than making up for their loss of 18 in 2019. The performance in terms of projected national vote share was however not good enough to justify Sir Keir's assertion that Labour was guaranteed an overall majority in a general election whenever it is held. The country is not totally convinced that new New Labour is the answer, as illustrated in Liverpool where the party, while retaining overall control of the city council, lost some wards to Liberal Democrats and Liverpool Community Independents.

None of the success in English council elections takes away from the need to refurbish the image of the Liberal Democrat party as a non-socialist alternative to Toryism, and one that prizes civil liberties. Peter Black draws attention to the current administration's increasing repression of public demonstrations, but one should not forget that New Labour introduced a law to prevent photography in public places at the discretion of the police and was intent on introducing compulsory identification cards.

[09-05-2023 13:00]

Redcar & Cleveland Longbeck ward result now in:

Stephen Crane (Independent) - 246 votes
Victor Jefferies (Independent) - 342 votes
Luke Myer (Labour and Co-operative Party) - 707 votes
Vera Rider (Independent) - 413 votes
Andrea Turner (Conservatives) - 409 votes
Stephen Turner (Conservatives) - 293 votes
Turnout - 40.68% 

 Elected - Luke Myer (Labour and Co-operative Party) & Vera Rider (Independent)

It looks as if this was a 3-member ward in 2019, two seats being taken by Conservatives, the other by an Independent. One of those Conservatives was the now-Independent Vera Rider. So this is at best one more seat lost by the Conservatives, making (e&oe) 1,062 lost councillors.



Monday, 8 May 2023

Good Energy slates greenwashing

 

Sunday, 7 May 2023

We must reverse the decline in the civil service

 We know the pattern. A bus company wants to get rid of a marginal route. First, they cut a couple of services. Then they can point to an overall drop in passenger numbers as a reason for cutting the service altogether. Readers will surely be familiar with similar ploys in other areas. Under the Tories, it is also happening in public administration.

Ian Birrell, writing in the i on Mayday,  identified a:

drive to blame "the Blob" for their failures with snide briefings about "snivel" servants who are supposed activists, anti-Brexit, sloppy snowflakes or workshy. Ministers complain their brilliant policies are being frustrated by obstructive bureaucrats. Boris Johnson even blamed them for his stupidity over the Partygate affair.

The civil service is not as resistant to change as failing politicians like to make out. I was only a junior civil servant in 1964 when Labour returned to power, but I attended seminars (possibly arranged through the CSCA staff union) at which senior civil servants spoke. I remember in particular Sir Eric Roll welcoming the proposals to improve economic planning. There was a sense of optimism and enthusiasm for a government under Harold Wilson which signalled a break with the past. Sadly, many of the aspirations went unfulfilled, broken not by the civil service but by the power over politicians by conservative trade unions,

For the sake of party balance, I cite Edward Heath's success in 1970 in pushing through accession to the EEC. Then, as now, Labour was predominantly Eurosceptic, but Conservative policy from Macmillan onwards was to join the European project. Colleagues closer to the ministerial floor than I observed that administrative civil servants known to favour closer European ties whose careers had advanced under Macmillan, then languished under Wilson, suddenly saw a boost to their prospects. That was an indication that top civil servants are not as immovable as the current Tories seem to believe. Later, Margaret Thatcher had an even more thorough putsch surrounding herself with more "people like us". It should be remembered that Sir Bernard Ingham, Mrs Thatcher's conduit to the press and strongly identified with her world view, was a civil servant. Indeed, a criticism of the Blair-Brown administration is that they were not as ruthless as they could have been in moving on those civil servants who were not sympathetic to Labour.

 There is a malaise in the service. The excessive use of financial and management consultants is partly responsible, as noted in a previous post. Then there is the host of special advisers (SpAds) which Baroness (Gisela) Stuart, a former Labour MP and later a Chair of the Civil Service Commission, drew attention to in her evidence to the Civil Service Appointments Inquiry. So far from reducing the number of SpAds as promised in election campaigning, Cameron and Clegg actually oversaw an increase. Numbers went up further after Conservatives gained an overall majority in 2015. The last official total from March last year was 126.

Clearly the status and morale of the civil service should be restored.  What needs to be done is to reduce the number of special advisers, taper off the reliance on management consultants, appoint competent ministers who may be trusted to remain in post for most of a parliament and to raise the salaries of top civil servants to the same bracket as those people with similar responsibilities in industry and finance. Sadly, this government is likely to do the reverse.

The Fulton Commission in 1968 drew attention to the culture of the generalist in the administrative civil service at the time. There were not enough specialists or competent managers. Nor was there any systematic career planning. The Civil Service Department and Civil Service College were set up as a result. They survived through two changes of administration until the radical shift in Conservative thinking under Thatcher and Heseltine. The latter, in devolving recruitment to Departments, also reversed a hard-won agreement from the 1960s for equal pay.

I would wind the clock back to the 1970s with one twist. Graduates with arts, especially classics, degrees tended to dominate the intake into the administrative civil service.  While a knowledge of ancient history is surprisingly valuable in addressing the international politics of today, and modern foreign languages are essential, science should not be neglected. I would introduce positive discrimination in favour of numerate and scientific degrees in recruitment such that arts and sciences were balanced fifty-fifty. It might not even be necessary to prolong this discrimination as the visibility of scientifically-educated civil servants at the top level increased.

(See also the view from a socialist in https://leftfootforward.org/2023/04/blame-it-on-the-blob-how-civil-servants-are-bearing-the-brunt-of-tory-government-failings/.) 


Saturday, 6 May 2023

Friday, 5 May 2023

Reflections on the English elections

 Some success, but we need to work on the long trek now. A frequent complaint of the average voter is that they do not know what the Liberal Democrats stand for. This feeling may have prevented the party doing even better at these elections.

The party campaign team has done well in issues of the moment, especially the pain of rising costs felt by people whose income has not risen to match. But we now need to fill in the background against which the foreground issues can be highlighted. 

If you really press the average voter as to what distinguishes the Liberal Democrats they will probably recall that we are the party of Europe. This is part of what we stand for  but only part. There is no need to bang on about what a failure Brexit has been; even former fervent Brexiteers realise that the British people are paying a heavy price for the country's isolation. Labour pretends that it can make Brexit work. We must point out that this is a fallacy and that restoring at least cooperation with continental Europe is essential if we are not to lose more national wealth.

The bigger picture is that we believe in freedom (though not anarchy). This is an important distinction between ourselves and Starmer's Labour  Sir Keir's public image as a bumbling moderate, burnished by his spoof column in Private Eye. However, within the party he has operated ruthlessly to suppress radical thought, disciplining  MPs and constituency parties alike. This is not a man who should be given absolute power nationally. Labour stands for central control while we stand for community.

A third  distinction between us and the other parties is our care about the environment which goes sway back to the days of the Liberal party. It is a commitment which we do not stress enough, especially as this government's warm words about following a green agenda are increasingly shown to be hollow.



Thursday, 4 May 2023

A Green measure, not socialist experimentation

 While activists in many local authority areas in England are desperately trying to whip in the final vote in council elections, the Welsh Senedd will be embarking on the second evidence session on a new government Bill. 

The Environment (Air Quality and Soundscapes) (Wales) Bill proposes:

  • to provide a framework for setting national air quality targets;
  • to amend existing legislation relating to the national air quality strategy; local air quality management; smoke control; clean air zones/low emission zones and vehicle idling;
  • to place a duty on Welsh Ministers to promote awareness of air pollution; and
  • to place a duty on Welsh Ministers to publish a national soundscape strategy.

The Bill is welcomed by Asthma + Lung UK (a merger of Asthma UK and the British Lung Foundation).

Wednesday, 3 May 2023

Is Angela Rayner on borrowed time?

 Private Eye no. 1596 asks:

Why might shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves be distancing Labour from what could be thought the vote-winning - never mind revenue-raising - idea of narrowing the gap between capital gains tax (20 percent) and income tax (40 or 45 percent for higher earners)?

"I don't have any plans to increase capital gains tax," she told BBC Radio 4 Today after PM Rishi Sunak's tax returns revealed that he pays tax at half the rate others do because most of his money comes as gains, not income. Oddly enough, Reeves' reluctance coincides with a dramatic rise in budget-bolstering donations to the Labour party from exactly the type of people who would be less than pleased if capital gains tax were to increase.

Lord (David) Sainsbury, who at the end of 2021 reportedly pumped a further £25m into an investment portfolio  already estimated at £1.1bn, and his daughter have given more than £3m in the past two years, £2m of which came in the most recently reported quarter. Meanwhile, ex-Tory donor and multi-millionaire Gareth Quarry, who calls himself a serial entrepreneur and angel investor, donated £30,000 to Labour last July. Scottish business tycoon Lord (William) Haughey has donated more than £200,000 to central and Scottish party branches since 2021.

Reeves' position is at odds with that of Labour's deputy Angela Rayner. The latter lashed out a tax system "in which the prime minister pays a far lower rate than working people", precisely because so much of his money comes from capital gains. But with Labour party finances at stake, even post-prime-ministerial Sunak wouldn't have much to fear from a Labour administration.

My guess is that Rayner, who was after all voted into her position as deputy leader, will keep her position, just as John Prescott was Tony Blair's deputy and token spokesman for the trade unions. But she will probably be advised to remain silent as the general election approaches. As a member of the Labour Friends of Palestine, repeatedly citing Israeli violations of human rights against Palestinians on social media (information from wikipedia) she has to tread a fine line for fear of being accused of anti-Semitism.


Tuesday, 2 May 2023

In Dyffryn woods

 



Sadly, my eyes are not as sharp as they used to be. All around I heard every sort of corvid except choughs and rooks, woodpeckers drumming, nuthatches and songbirds. Could I catch a glimpse of any of them? Could I thump!