Sunday, 18 June 2023

"That's TV" ownership

 Researching the fate of Bay TV turned up some interesting facts. That's TV, the company that now owns the local TV licence, was co-founded by Esther Rantzen of That's Life fame - thus explaining the company name. Ms Rantzen has now given up all her directorships, including most recently the two charities she founded. 

As a private company, That's TV is fairly opaque to enquiries. Even more opaque (as far as the Web is concerned, anyway) is the origin of its sole proprietor, Daniel Cass. What is clear is that he believes in sweating assets as the experience of That's Solent demonstrates.

Cass can be criticised for making the most of the opportunity for profit with little concern for the spirit of local TV legislation. However, more blame should be attached to Ofcom and the Conservative politicians who have not forced operators to respect the original remit.


Saturday, 17 June 2023

Interest rate hikes do not combat inflation

As Alpesh Patel pointed out on BBC Business News during the week. the use of lending rate to damp down inflation has failed. What is likely to be more effective is to reduce spending power by raising tax rates, but no politician dare do this.

It was good to hear a trained economist confirm what this non-economist had long suspected. I would go further and suggest that raising bank lending rate increases domestic price inflation in the short term as those entities having to pay more in interest will pass the cost on to consumers.

If the conventional economic theory of the Phillips Curve ever worked, it was by slugging an economy, stifling investment and throwing people out of work so that less money circulates. But it seems to me that each application of the interest rate shillelagh makes succeeding inflation incidence worse as indebted companies are driven out of business leaving fewer providers in the market.
 


Friday, 16 June 2023

Which is more humane, the gas chamber or the Work Capability Assessment?

 https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m001mck1 refers

Inspired by the "science" of eugenics, Nazi Germany sterilised or put to death the long-term disabled, particularly the mentally-troubled, in the interests of creating the supermen and -women of the master race. This was before they got round to the homosexuals, Slavs and Jews.

We do not believe in such crude stuff. Instead, we label such people as "shirkers" and deny them benefits. Is it any wonder that so many have taken their own lives? From the time that the cold-blooded Peter Lilley set the programme of discrimination in motion, no government or political party has been free of blame.

Now the WCA is to be abolished. In the last programme of his series, Jolyon Jenkins asks whether its replacement is going to be any better.




Thursday, 15 June 2023

Covid-19 Inquiry timetable favours Conservatives' general election chances

 Private Eye reckons

it's good news for government that the inquiry has said it won't look at events in chronological order. Thus the successful vaccine roll-out will be scrutinised before the election, but how the virus spread through care homes isn't scheduled until summer 2024. With an election likely in autumn 2024, the inquiry won't be able to hold hearings during an election campaign, so the care home deaths module will likely be delayed until afterwards.

The inquiry could still publish its interim analysis of pandemic preparedness and the government's initial response before the election - but only if it receives the evidence it needs in time. 

That timeframe will also be a relief to the Welsh ministers in post at the time the epidemic was taking hold here. First Minister Mark Drakeford and Health Minister Vaughan Gething were the men in charge. Gething has since been replaced by Eluned Morgan and Drakeford may well have sent in his promised resignation letter by the time the inquiry takes evidence from Wales. They must feel that denying a Wales-only Inquiry, which may well have been able to report more swiftly than Hallett, was justified in keeping out of the line of fire until it did not matter. 

There was a further item in Private Eye about the Inquiry which is difficult to believe until you see the official confirmation:

Renowned art curator Ekow Eshun has been appointed to oversee the co-creation of a modern tapestry for the UK Covid-19 Inquiry that will capture the experiences and emotions of people across the UK during the pandemic. Ekow is Chairman of the Fourth Plinth Commissioning Group, overseeing one of the UK’s foremost public art programmes.

Ekow will curate the tapestry, which will feature panels produced by different artists over the coming months. The Inquiry is working with a range of organisations and individuals across the UK to identify stories to inspire each panel.


This is an egregious waste of public money when one considers that such a tapestry already exists. It is shortly to find a permanent home with the Chelsea and Westminster Hospital Trust after a tour of the UK:

The Covid Chronicle was set up by artist Wendy Bliss during the February UK Lockdown, 2021. The completed project is made up of 142 submissions from around the world, and the panels have been curated and stitched together into metre square blocks of four, making a total of 36 metres of work. The installation has been described as a ‘Bayeux Tapestry’ for the 21st century pandemic, and records personal experience in words as well as pictures: each artist has been invited to add words to support their panel for this extraordinary collection; these are often poetic or moving, and always interesting.

 

Wednesday, 14 June 2023

Who is standing up for traditional British values?

 In last Sunday's World This Weekend radio programme, presenter James Naughtie introduced a discussion on the implications of the latest Johnson episode.

It raises questions about parliamentary behaviour, honours lists and their place in our democracy and maybe the whole system of checks and balances that are effectively our alternative to a written constitution. 

The veteran (born 1953) Conservative MP, Sir Geoffrey Clinton-Brown, agreed with Naughtie that:

It demeans and reduces the status of parliament and members of parliament. It is clearly a very bad thing. 

Naughtie turned to Dame Margaret Beckett, the woman MP with the longest overall service in the Commons, for a description of the saga's effect on parliament and public debate. 

Funnily enough, I was having a conversation with a colleague about it in a different context the other day and we were talking about, in the future, how do you get a better balance of responsibilities and where blame is shared, if any, and so on. Part-way through the conversation we suddenly realised that actually the easiest and best way to do it would be this way, relatively light touch and then we realised the only reason we are not discussing doing it that way is because of Boris Johnson and the way he's behaved ever since he became prime minister, because no longer can people kind of say "well, of course, nobody would do that, you know it would be unprecedented, it would be outrageous", and then you realise that Boris has destroyed all those comfortable assumptions. 

Studio guest Gus O'Donnell (70), former head of the civil service, was asked by Naughtie to speak on behalf of the Establishment, which Johnson had railed against in his resignation message. Lord O'Donnell was more sanguine about our system:

When you look at the US, Congress and the Republican party are really struggling with how to handle Donald Trump. In the UK, we've had a situation where we have a prime minister, who hasn't behaved well, but the checks and balances in our system for prime ministers, you know, it's their party. So it's Tory MPs that decided they didn't want Boris Johnson as their leader. As Mr Johnson the MP has behaved badly in parliament, it's parliament that's done this. .... Conservatives have to ask themselves, constitutionally do you want to put something above our sovereign parliament to second-guess it when it doesn't give you the answers you want?

Asked about Johnson's characterisation of the civil service as The Blob, Lord O'Donnell said:

Effective government is all about civil service and government working together which works at its best when government is very clear what it wants to do, and the civil service is there in its role to test that and ask challenging questions, but once government has decided what to do, to get on and deliver it.

In the last few years, he admitted, that view of the world:

has struggled, to be perfectly honest, because you've had prime ministers, you've had special advisers, who've abused the system and that's becoming more and more obvious ... I think the current prime minister is beginning to rebuild that trust in our government, in our institutions ... it is sad, because I see my former civil service losing a lot of talent - people are somewhat disillusioned and we need to attract them back.

[...]

The only time you find parliament struggling is when you get an executive - the government - saying to parliament "please do things which are not in line with the law". Parliament's job - and this is what the House of Lords has been doing a lot of - is to say "if you want to do that, go ahead by all means, but change the law first and get that through parliament but you can't do it under the law as it exists" 

Naughtie and O'Donnell agreed that the deal which enabled our system of government to function without a written constitution, an understanding across party political boundaries, labelled the "good chaps" theory by Peter Hennessy , is under unprecedented strain. Lord O'Donnell however remained optimistic, the checks and balances of party and parliamentary committee having worked in the case of Boris Johnson.

A later guest, the decade-younger Danny Finkelstein, was not so sure. He saw Johnson and his allies taking the fight outside parliament and was not certain that it would be unsuccessful. 

Clifton-Brown, Beckett, O'Donnell and Hennessy are roughly all of the generation which, growing up, saw the reestablishment of the rule of law in nations devastated by the actions of dictators who had overridden it - not to mention the removal in |Britain of the restrictions on civil liberties imposed by a wartime government. Where are the younger people prepared to defend publicly our system of government? I exempt the millennials from criticism. Young adults have always been more exercised about specific causes before developing more of a world view. I am more concerned about the generation between us, "Thatcher's children" if you like. Adam Smith, Walter Bagehot and John Stuart Mill were in their late forties or early fifties when they wrote the books for which they are most famous. Where are the middle-aged defenders of liberal government today?




Tuesday, 13 June 2023

What does Labour stand for?

I am grateful to Lord Bonkers for the link to an article by the always-perceptive Michael Crick. Crick shows that, far from the weak and vacillating post-holder that the media make him out to be, Sir Keir Starmer is a ruthless operator. The article lists examples of Starmer and a few key executives able to eliminate candidates with any taint of socialism from selection contests, irrespective of the Labour Party's committees' views. (Welsh Labour has not gone quite that far, but presumably nudged by London has allegedly rigged ballots in favour of conservative candidates. The forthcoming merger of the Merthyr Tydfil and Cynon Valley seats, eliminating one of the two current Labour MPs, provides a case in point.)

What worries me is that Starmer also seems to want to replace anti-Semitism in the party (a laudable aim in itself) with Islamophobia. Not only the socialist tradition within the party is being discriminated against, but also many loyal, mainstream Muslim activists and those who protest Israeli prime minister Netanyahu's attack on civil rights.

It is known that openly-divided parties suffer in the polls. Starmer seems to have gone to the opposite extreme. But, as Crick points out:

Past Labour governments, by contrast, have always thrived on being a “broad church”. Attlee’s cabinet counted Nye Bevan and Stafford Cripps among its towering figures, yet both had suffered periods of expulsion from the party only a few years before. Wilson’s benefited from the presence of Dick Crossman and Barbara Castle; Callaghan had Tony Benn and Michael Foot (another former expellee), while Blair’s deputy John Prescott had been one of the “tightly knit group of politically motivated men” denounced by Wilson during the 1966 seamen’s strike.

As the experiences of both Boris Johnson and Liz Truss demonstrated, it’s a mistake to confine ones government to a narrow band of loyal yes-men and women. Cabinet government needs the odd maverick, people who are willing to come up with alternative ideas and scrutinise and challenge existing policy. “Keir is blocking off his exits,” a former Corbyn aide recently told him. “You need some people who are creating space, and who enable the party to be a bit bolder.”


There is always a danger of people at the top of a party hierarchy acting as dictators, even in such a liberal organisation as the Liberal Democrats. The quarantines of the last few years have tended to produce an in-group effect at the top. Before the next general election, efforts must be made to return to our open and tolerant tradition. We must follow Labour down a bland and featureless path. 

Sunday, 11 June 2023

Lords reform has become more urgent

 Boris Johnson's delayed prime ministerial resignation honours list briefly made headline news on Friday. It was soon swept off TV news reports by the double resignations as MPs of Nadine Dorries and Johnson himself. This has inhibited discussion of the implications of the honours list which blatantly comprises only those who have done favours for Johnson. The devaluation of orders of chivalry is bad enough,  but not as dangerous as the awarding of peerages to those who are unlikely to make a positive contribution to the upper house of the UK parliament.

In 2012, an unholy alliance of the Labour opposition and Conservative back-benchers, by blocking a timetable motion, ensured that the Lords Reform Bill initiated by the Liberal Democrats would not make progress in the Commons. It was therefore shelved.

Labour has since recognised that Lords reform is popular. A commission chaired by former PM Gordon Brown has drawn up a complex scheme for an elected upper House based upon the regions and nations of the UK. 

The Brown scheme addresses one flaw which the 2012 Bill did not, the London and home counties bias of the current chamber. It does place too much emphasis on party when one of the few benefits of the current Lords is the large number of cross-benchers. Peers who are not burdened by party allegiance can and do make valuable contributions because of their very independence. On balance, though, Brown represents progress.

The question is: could a Labour government be trusted to carry reform through? In 1998, a commission chaired by a former Labour grandee came forward with a proposal for Commons electoral reform. Then, as now, Labour was led by a man from the conservative wing of the party. Tony Blair, buoyed by an unexpectedly large majority from the 1997 election decided that reform was not in Labour's interests and did not proceed with the Jenkins proposals. 

Current public opinion ratings notwithstanding, it is unlikely that Labour will have an overwhelming majority at the next election.  They will  thus have to take third party opinion into account and we may at last have the Lords reform we need.


Saturday, 10 June 2023

Our "local" TV station

 Bay TV was set up in 2013 with the best of intentions to fulfil Conservative culture minister Jeremy Hunt's stated aim of 

providing truly local content that is more relevant to local people and leading the way for a multitude of local TV stations across the UK. My vision for local TV is one which contributes to future economic growth and social wellbeing in the UK. Local TV will be a driver of growth in the media and creative industries; helping to increase local employment and skills and boosting local businesses. It will also have a vital role in contributing to local democracy. With Royal Assent being given to the Localism Bill last month and the planned referenda on new locally elected Mayors and Police and Crime Commissioners, local TV will have an important role in holding local politicians to account through coverage of local news and current affairs. 

It has to be admitted that the technical and presentation standards of the new station were not as polished as the established national broadcasters. However, these would surely have improved with time - time that the new station was not given. Deaths of key personnel seemed to drain the energy of the enterprise, whose model became financially unsustainable. Bay TV was wound up and the licence sold. The licence is now held, along with 15 other services, by a private company, That's TV.

On Wednesday last, it was announced that "after a period of consultation", 

Local television services across the country will remain on air until 2034, under new proposals set out by the Government. All 34 of the UK’s local TV stations will have their licenses renewed, subject to a review of individual future plans.

Plans set out by the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) will allow media regulator Ofcom to review each station’s plans to continue meeting the needs of local audiences.

The current licenses are currently due to expire in 2025.

Launched in 2013, local TV services are accessible to 15 million people and are required to show a number of hours of local programming each day.

“While recognising the challenges they have faced, particularly during the pandemic, the Government believes that local TV services continue to play a role in the wider broadcasting ecosystem,” the DCMS said.

“Many services, such as Notts TV in Nottingham and KMTV in Kent, also boost local journalism through training programmes provided in production, news reporting and technical roles, which enable students to gain hands-on experience.”

Minister John Whittingdale said: “Local TV stations from Belfast to Birmingham help to support local journalism, drive the creative economy and foster pride in communities.

“We want to see this continue, so we’ve set out plans for Ofcom to review all services to ensure they’re well positioned to continue serving local audiences with trusted and distinctive content for years to come.”

The DCMS statement is disingenuous. Notts TV and KMTV are the exception, rather than the rule. Only a handful of truly local services remain, as this wikipedia article shows. That's TV owns nearly half the licences, streaming repeats of past TV programmes to its satellite stations from its Manchester HQ. Nine of the other licences are held by Local TV Ltd. 

Minister Whittingdale, a long-time opponent of non-commercial broadcasting, has refused to admit that Local TV has, apart from a half-dozen of localities, been a failure. It is to be hoped that an incoming DCMS minister after the next election sticks to the original timetable and revokes the licences of TV stations which are local in name only.